When They Go Low, We Go High 10 Sep 2018
The European Parliament’s decision not to immediately pass the new EU Copyright Directive in July was seen by many as a major setback. It was defeated by 318 to 278, a margin of 40 votes. This means the proposed legislation now moves forward to a full plenary debate and vote next Wednesday 12 September.
As the music industry faces this pivotal moment, it is worth reflecting how we got here and what we are now facing.
The creative industries as a whole have long argued that embryonic digital legislation passed in the mid 1990s is outdated and simply not fit for purpose. The legislative process is slow at the best of times. Meanwhile, the tech industry “moved fast and broke things,” incurring the wrath of creators whose livelihoods have been upended as a result.
The publication of the draft EU Copyright Directive in late 2016 was an achievement in itself. Not only did the draft legislation address copyright protection and safe harbour loopholes, it also contained provisions concerning fairness and transparency towards creators. Following further debate and lobbying, is even more of an achievement that the key elements of the draft directive remain mostly intact.
The Directive has not been without it’s critics, as is the case with any proposed legislation. Academics, libraries and dignitaries such as Sir Tim Berners-Lee have all put forth concerns. We in the music industry can acknowledge some concerns as understandable even if we believe they are unfounded.
What is not understandable are the thoroughly vile and dishonest tactics deployed during the course of this year, whose objective is to stop the legislation in its tracks at any cost. The scale of this activity reads like set pieces straight out of the Cambridge Analytica playbook.
Some in the music industry have questioned how we fight back given the vast funding involved and the sheer scale of this enterprise. But fight back we must and the actions of those we face only serve to give us greater strength.
As any Jiu-Jitsu grandmaster will tell you: use your opponents’ force against them. In this case, we should call out the deceitful actions from within the tech sector and elsewhere and those actions speak louder than any words.
The Financial Times reported some MEPs received death threats
MEPs were each bombarded with over 60,000 emails from bots
These emails contained identical content according to The Trichordist
The same blog named the domain name from which a large number of these emails originated and its link to a US Inc. entity.
The same tactics have been found on Twitter: multiple bot accounts promoting #SaveOurInternet and similar hashtags
This contrasts to real world protests that only drew a few hundred protestors combined across Europe. The bots did not show up.
These actions must also be viewed against the current backdrop where tech firms have been scrutinised for avoiding responsibility concerning:
Blatantly dishonest content
Content that incites hatred and violence
Little accountability in how such content is disseminated
Minimal transparency in how user data is abused in facilitating all this
Mark Zuckerberg and Jack Dorsey are amongst those tech executives rebuked by lawmakers on both sides of the Atlantic, for failing to take responsibility and failing to act in managing their own platforms. This is reflective of a broader failure that lies at the heart of a misguided and libertarian ideal, that somehow tech firms are exempt from laws and rules that govern the rest of the world.
The music industry and broader creative and media industries are made up of real people, filled with passion and blood pumping through their veins. They compose their own emails, speak to politicians and show up in person.
At the UK Music organized #LoveMusic busking event in London earlier today, artists, executives and even politicians turned out in support. Artists such as Brett Anderson, Ed Harcourt, Dave Rowntree, Madeleina Kay, Newton Faulkner and BASCA Chair Crispin Hunt. In addition a number of cross party British MPs who support the directive including Tom Watson, Nigel Evans and Kevin Brennan were amongst those in attendance.
One has to ask, if those opposing the EU Copyright Directive have such a compelling argument, why do they resort to such deceitful means? If we judge their actions, the arguments of those opposed to the directive hold no legitimacy and the European Parliament should vote in favour of the directive.
Andy Edwards, music manager and consultant
NEWS & PRESS
The Weeknd's Blinding Lights takes early singles lead Viral TikTok hits from Roddy Ricch, Doja Cat and Trevor Daniel make strong impact Eminem, J Hus and BTS among biggest new albums of the year so far while Lewis Capaldi's debut continues its...more
BBC Radio 1 launches a new Friday night schedule which will see presenters Danny Howard, Annie Mac and Pete Tong continue to showcase the station’s premiere electronic music talent, with Howard moving to the 9-11pm show from this Friday (3rd...more
"Get your hit together": BMAT rolls out initiative to help music creators to maximize royalties in response to COVID-19
As the COVID-19 outbreak continues to disturb the world economy, emerging music artists are among the most financially affected. With tours being canceled so that ticket sales are no longer bringing in revenue and with both labels and independent artists...more
The Entertainment Retailers Association (ERA) has paid tribute to former Chairman Paul Quirk who died yesterday (April 2) at home after a short battle with cancer.ERA CEO Kim Bayley said, "ERA is indebted to Paul Quirk. Not only was he...more
Marathon Music Group has announced the appointment of Ophelia Conheady as Head of A&R for its main label imprint, Marathon Artists. Highly regarded by both the artist community and her music industry peers, Ophelia joins the company from her previous position...more
The role is the first created since Chrysalis Records returned to releasing new music Blue Raincoat Chrysalis Group today further strengthened their senior team with the appointment of John Leahy in the newly created position of SVP Marketing and Strategy. Leahy...more
BBC Radio 1 are set to launch a brand new home for undiscovered dance music this Sunday night, designed solely to showcase the next wave of emerging electronic talent. At the helm is rising star and trusted tastemaker and DJ, Jaguar.Following on...more
Music sector joins together to call for EU and national investment to address current crisis and promote diversity
Music is one of the first sectors hit by the unprecedented COVID-19 crisis. It will also be one of the last. As borders close, venues as well as festivals suspend their activities, performances are cancelled, group activity is stopped, shops close,...more
VIRGIN EMI PRESENTS LOCKDOWN LIVE IN SUPPORT OF GLOBAL CITIZEN AND THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANISATION’S COVID-19 SOLIDARITY RESPONSE FUND 32 ACTS PERFORMING ACROSS 3 DAYS INCLUDING THE GRAMMY NOMINATED US POP SUPERSTARS ALESSIA CARA AND TORI KELLY, BRIT NOMINEE CALUM SCOTT,...more
Toolroom has appointed electronic music specialist Dispersion PR to handle the company's media communications
In its second decade of operations, Dispersion PR has a client list which takes in underground stalwarts like Rekids, Cocoon and Phantasy as well as Ministry of Sound, BMG and Polydor. 'We're really inspired by Toolroom's growing operations and ambition,' said...more
GUY & CARIANNE STATEMENT “Mike’s decided to leave the company for family reasons. He’s been an integral part of the Warner Chappell story over the last few years and we’re grateful for everything he’s achieved. We’re sorry to see him leave...more
The urgency for Guest House came from the situation forced upon us all by the global outbreak of the Coronavirus. Guest House allows musicians to maintain desperately needed income during this difficult time and it also allows fans to get...more
An update from Boiler Room x Ballantine's True Music projectAs I'm sure you've experienced first-hand the worsening situation of COVID-19 has exposed the real fragility of underground music. From mass cancellations, to restricted access to resources, with artists and other members...more
Your Streaming as a Service Provider LiveFrom Events is our simple-to-use Streaming as a Service platform. We wanted to make it easyfor creators, producers and artists to run small intimate shows and yet connect and engage with all their fans worldwide.And...more
ARA, A2IM, MAC, NMPA, NSAI, Recording Academy,Â RIAA, andÂ Sona join forces on website offering guidance, resources for music community
Leading artist rights organizations including the Artist Rights Alliance (ARA), American Association of Independent Music (A2IM), the Music Artists Coalition (MAC), National Music Publishers' Association (NMPA), Nashville Songwriters Association International (NSAI), the Recording Academy, the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA),...more
It is fantastic news that so many Landlords from across the UK have joined with us at this very difficult time. We are of course, all in this together which is why The NTIA and many British Landlords are asking...more
As announced this morning on Jason Mraz's newly launched weekly livestreamed series, "La La La Livestream," Grammy Award-winning, multi-Platinum artist Jason Mraz has signed a new global recordings agreement with BMG. The multi-album deal encompasses three full-length studio recordings with...more
The Americana Music Association UK (AMA-UK) has today announced that the BBC's "Whispering Bob" Harris and Mumford & Sons' Ben Lovett will join the organisation's Board. The two long-term supporters of the genre join British singer-songwriter and Americana trailblazer Billy Bragg,...more
OVER 4,000 DELEGATES FROM 27 DIFFERENT COUNTRIES ATTENDED AIM SYNC 2020 NEWLY UPDATED VERSION OF AIM SYNC GUIDE LAUNCHED WINNERS OF THE FIRST EVER AIM INDEPENDENT SYNC AWARDS ANNOUNCED How does the Association of Independent Music (AIM) respond to a global pandemic? By...more
One Media iP (AIM:OMIP), the digital media content provider which exploits intellectual digital property rights around music, video and copyright technology, announces its Full Year Results for the 12-month period ended 31 October 2019. Financial Highlights Revenue increased 30% to £3,508,891 (2018: £2,702,374) EBITDA...more
8.5 million people tuned in to watch Beatport's 34-hour live stream marathon with DJs from around the globe, raising over $180,000 for the AFEM (Association for Electronic Music) and WHO COVID-19 Funds Beatport, the world's leading destination for electronic music, today announced that its...more
SyncFloor, the commercial music marketplace, is announcing its partnership with Motor Music, bringing the label's catalog to more potential sync buyers via its newly launched Motor Music SyncSite. SyncFloor's SyncSites allow its rights holder partners to surface a sync-oriented website...more
BMG has further strengthened the leadership of its fast-growing BMG Production Music (BMGPM) business unit with the appointment of Dan Pounder to head finance, operations and systems. He will jointly run BMGPM with EVP & Global Managing Director John Clifford. BMG...more
Share your support for your local independent retailer using the hashtag #recordstoreoftheday to win vouchers of up to £150 OVERVIEW: In light of the unprecedented challenge currently faced by independent retailers, the UK record business has launched the #recordstoreoftheday campaign to help...more
Hipgnosis Songs Fund Limited (“Hipgnosis” or the “Company”) Acquisition of Music Catalogue The Board of Hipgnosis Songs Fund Limited and its Investment Adviser, The Family (Music) Limited, are pleased to announce that the Company has acquired the music catalogue of Songwriters Hall...more
Right now, most of us are home with our families. Deezer wants to make sure you have the right tunes and podcasts to pass the time. So we've kicked off a new offer that lets you try Deezer Family and...more
UK Music has appointed former Shadow Culture Secretary Tom Watson as the new chair of UK Music. He succeeds outgoing chair Andy Heath CBE and will start in April at UK Music, the umbrella body for the whole of the commercial...more
Music Venue Trust is calling on the music industry, cultural sector and the UK’s most successful musicians to come together to create a £1 million fighting fund to prevent the permanent closure of hundreds of Grassroots Music Venues across the UK. Despite Government action, over 550 Grassroots Music Venues remain...more
Deal with LatinAutor will allow IMPEL to license and collect across Argentina, Colombia, Uruguay and moreIMPEL has expanded its services to Latin America after signing a licensing and administration agreement with LatinAutor.LatinAutor (also known as One Stop Shop) is a...more
Loren McShane joins as Head of Legal and Business AffairsDr. Joe Watson takes Data Scientist roleSentric Music Group has made two important additions to its team with the hiring of Loren McShane as Head of Legal and Business Affairs, and...more
Mike Smith stands down as Warner Chappell MD (see Business)
European music organisations urge increase of budgets dedicated to music (see News)
Spotify and Warner Music Group announce renewed global licensing partnership (see Business)
Blue Raincoat appoints John Leahy; Marathon appoints Ophelia Conheady (see Business)
Kobalt reports increased losses but strong revenue growth (see Business)
Vivendi closes sale of stake in Universal Music Group to Tencent consortium (see Business)
TikTok strikes short-term licensing deals with majors (see Digital)
Eurovision Song Contest to be broadcast in live, non-competitive format (see Media)
Tom Watson appointed Chair of UK Music (see Business)
OCC and ERA working to expand the number of independent retailers reporting home delivery sales to the Official Charts (see News)
Hipgnosis acquires Richie Sambora catalogue (see Deals)
PPL announces £87.6m Q1 distribution, plus additional measures to help the music community (see News)
MMF and FAC survey suggests £50m has been lost to the wider music economy (see Analysis)
Music industry welcomes 'vital lifeline' for self-employed, but warns two month wait too long (see News)
Download and Isle of Wight festivals cancelled (see News)
Radio 1, 6 Music to streamline schedules; Annie Mac comes off air (see Media)
Spotify, PRS For Music and Help Musicians launch coronavirus relief fund (see News)
BMG report 10.1% revenue rise for 2019 (see Business)
IMPALA's Covid-19 Task Force publishes package of ten recommendations (see News)
The Great Escape 2020 has been cancelled (see News)
HMV closes all 120 of its UK stores due to coronavirus (see Business)
Kenny Rogers dies (see News)
Industry calls for help for self-employed (see Comment)