When They Go Low, We Go High 10 Sep 2018
The European Parliament’s decision not to immediately pass the new EU Copyright Directive in July was seen by many as a major setback. It was defeated by 318 to 278, a margin of 40 votes. This means the proposed legislation now moves forward to a full plenary debate and vote next Wednesday 12 September.
As the music industry faces this pivotal moment, it is worth reflecting how we got here and what we are now facing.
The creative industries as a whole have long argued that embryonic digital legislation passed in the mid 1990s is outdated and simply not fit for purpose. The legislative process is slow at the best of times. Meanwhile, the tech industry “moved fast and broke things,” incurring the wrath of creators whose livelihoods have been upended as a result.
The publication of the draft EU Copyright Directive in late 2016 was an achievement in itself. Not only did the draft legislation address copyright protection and safe harbour loopholes, it also contained provisions concerning fairness and transparency towards creators. Following further debate and lobbying, is even more of an achievement that the key elements of the draft directive remain mostly intact.
The Directive has not been without it’s critics, as is the case with any proposed legislation. Academics, libraries and dignitaries such as Sir Tim Berners-Lee have all put forth concerns. We in the music industry can acknowledge some concerns as understandable even if we believe they are unfounded.
What is not understandable are the thoroughly vile and dishonest tactics deployed during the course of this year, whose objective is to stop the legislation in its tracks at any cost. The scale of this activity reads like set pieces straight out of the Cambridge Analytica playbook.
Some in the music industry have questioned how we fight back given the vast funding involved and the sheer scale of this enterprise. But fight back we must and the actions of those we face only serve to give us greater strength.
As any Jiu-Jitsu grandmaster will tell you: use your opponents’ force against them. In this case, we should call out the deceitful actions from within the tech sector and elsewhere and those actions speak louder than any words.
-
The Financial Times reported some MEPs received death threats
-
MEPs were each bombarded with over 60,000 emails from bots
-
These emails contained identical content according to The Trichordist
-
The same blog named the domain name from which a large number of these emails originated and its link to a US Inc. entity.
-
The same tactics have been found on Twitter: multiple bot accounts promoting #SaveOurInternet and similar hashtags
-
This contrasts to real world protests that only drew a few hundred protestors combined across Europe. The bots did not show up.
These actions must also be viewed against the current backdrop where tech firms have been scrutinised for avoiding responsibility concerning:
-
Blatantly dishonest content
-
Content that incites hatred and violence
-
Little accountability in how such content is disseminated
-
Minimal transparency in how user data is abused in facilitating all this
Mark Zuckerberg and Jack Dorsey are amongst those tech executives rebuked by lawmakers on both sides of the Atlantic, for failing to take responsibility and failing to act in managing their own platforms. This is reflective of a broader failure that lies at the heart of a misguided and libertarian ideal, that somehow tech firms are exempt from laws and rules that govern the rest of the world.
The music industry and broader creative and media industries are made up of real people, filled with passion and blood pumping through their veins. They compose their own emails, speak to politicians and show up in person.
At the UK Music organized #LoveMusic busking event in London earlier today, artists, executives and even politicians turned out in support. Artists such as Brett Anderson, Ed Harcourt, Dave Rowntree, Madeleina Kay, Newton Faulkner and BASCA Chair Crispin Hunt. In addition a number of cross party British MPs who support the directive including Tom Watson, Nigel Evans and Kevin Brennan were amongst those in attendance.
One has to ask, if those opposing the EU Copyright Directive have such a compelling argument, why do they resort to such deceitful means? If we judge their actions, the arguments of those opposed to the directive hold no legitimacy and the European Parliament should vote in favour of the directive.
Andy Edwards, music manager and consultant
@andyedwardsbiz
NEWS & PRESS
Ivors Academy members elects new Senate to champion songwriters and composers at the heart of its governance
The Ivors Academy has announced the election of 40 songwriters and composers to its Senate. Elected by members, the Senate plays an essential role in representing the interests and rights of songwriters and composers. Through the body, the views and...more
Musexpo 2025 to celebrate 25 years of industry transformation with a groundbreaking keynote panel featuring Bob Bowen & Amazon MGM Studios' global music team
MUSEXPO (www.musexpo.net), “The United Nations of Music,” is thrilled to announce its 25th global edition, scheduled to take place from March 16 - March 19, 2025, in Burbank, California “The Media & Sync Capital of the World.” Over the past...more
R-Trybe Launches New Artist-Driven Label and Community for Electronic Music Creatives
R-Trybe is hyped to announce the launch of its label alongside an inclusive artist-driven community, a concept inspired by Huxley (Defected, Toolroom, Aus), Ramin Rezaie (Solid Grooves, Silky), and BAKKIS (Dumb Safari). With a combined mission to create a welcoming space...more
Nicholas Salomone Promoted to SVP, Business Development and Revenue at CD Baby
Salomone will drive revenue growth and partnerships at CD Baby, while advancing cross-company initiatives at Downtown to expand services for independent artists. Downtown Music’s direct-to-creator division, CD Baby, today announced the promotion of Nicholas Salomone to SVP, Business Development and Revenue,...more
Koko: A Night In The Theatre
Further special guests will be revealed on the night, joining Benedict Cumberbatch in his new role as KOKO Foundation global ambassador for environmental advocacy “A Night In The Theatre”, a special fundraising edition of Letters Live, will take place in aid...more
FAC AGM 2024
FAC Artist In Residence, David Rowntree, urges industry to listen to the artist’s voice on grassroots music, AI and music streaming Tributes paid to FAC founding member, Howard Jones, who steps down from board Incoming board member, Alt-J’s Gus Unger-Hamilton, joins a...more
Jamie Cullum, East 17's Tony Mortimer and Lemar to perform at special London Carol Service for music therapy charity Nordoff and Robbins
Carol Service takes place at St Luke’s Church in Chelsea, London, on Tuesday 10 December 2024 Hosted by Smooth Radio presenter Angie Greaves with guests, Nordoff and Robbins ambassadors Carrie and David Grant, plus reader Jemma Redgrave Nordoff and Robbins, the UK’s...more
Graham Lyle to be honoured as a BMI Icon at the 2024 BMI London Awards
The Ceremony Also Celebrates the Top British and European Songwriters, Composers and Music Publishers of the Previous Year BMI today announced that Graham Lyle will be presented with the BMI Icon Award at the 2024 BMI London Awards to be held 9 December at The Savoy. The legendary songwriter, guitarist and...more
PRS for Music celebrates British IP Day: Chief Strategy, Communications & Public Affairs Officer calls to protect intellectual property of music creators in the face of AI adoption
Last night, John Mottram, Chief Strategy, Communications & Public Affairs Officer at PRS for Music, addressed MPs, policymakers, government officials, songwriters and composers, at the House of Commons on British IP Day. The parliamentary reception, hosted by Pete Wishart MP and The Alliance...more
Warner Chappell Music sign Irish up and coming band Florence Road
Warner Chappell Music (WCM), the music publishing arm of Warner Music Group, has signed a worldwide publishing deal with exciting, up and coming band, Florence Road. The all-girl quartet from Wicklow, Ireland, have quickly built a growing, organic, fan base and...more
ASCAP and Sacem Announce Multi-Initiative Strategic Alliance
ASCAP, the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, and Sacem, La Société des Auteurs, Compositeurs et Editeurs de Musique, two of the world’s premiere collective management organizations, announce the formation of a strategic alliance. The two Societies will leverage...more
beatBread joins the WIN Supporters program
Just weeks after sponsoring and participating in WIN's annual conference, WINCON, in Belgrade (Serbia) beatBread joins the WIN Supporters program to champion the global independent music community. Founded in 2020, beatBread is a pioneering music finance company that provides artists and record labels...more
Paul Cousins presents Atomised Listening
Paul Cousins presents ATOMISED LISTENING Interactive sound installation using obsolete technology Stone Nest, London | 22-23 November 2024 Sound artist and musician Paul Cousins has announced Atomised Listening - an interactive two day analog sound exhibition at the legendary arts venue Stone Nest in...more
Music collaboration platform Ampollo announces three key hires
Jolyon Mason, Tong Li and Anthony Walters join Company in Senior Positions AMPOLLO, the groundbreaking new platform that allows artists, songwriters and producers at all levels to practice, record, collaborate, network and drive revenue has announced three senior hires across key...more
Sony Music Publishing Signs Global Deal with Mike Dean; Launches Partnership with M.W.A.
Acclaimed M.W.A producers Sean Solymar, Tommy Rush, Sage Skolfield sign with SMP Sony Music Publishing today announced the signing of legendary producer Mike Dean and several members of his renowned producer collective M.W.A., including Sean Solymar, Tommy Rush and Sage Skolfield....more
O2 Academy Brixton Unveils Cutting-Edge Audio and Lighting Systems in Major Technical Upgrade
Iconic London Venue Sets New Standard for Live Music Experiences The iconic, Grade II listed O2 Academy Brixton has undergone a transformative renovation, solidifying its status as one of the world's premier live music destinations. This comprehensive upgrade, which includes state-of-the-art...more
Disclosure, Dixon and Imogen Heap join deadmau5 and Richie Hawtin's KOR Protocol Advisory Team
KOR Protocol, a cutting-edge entertainment protocol that reshapes how intellectual property is managed, distributed, and monetized has announced that a team of globally acclaimed artists will join the blockchain and AI-powered protocol as advisors. British recording artist and Grammy...more
Universal Music Publishing Group, in collaboration with Organized Chaos, extends agreement with multi-platinum hit maker Tim Powell
Universal Music Publishing Group (UMPG), a leading, global music publishing company, in collaboration with indie dance music publisher, Organized Chaos, today announces the extension of its exclusive, worldwide publishing deal with prolific songwriter, Tim Powell.For 14 years, as a key member...more
ICMP & Creative Industries' Letter on implementing EU AI Act
ICMP has co-written a joint letter with European creative industries, creators and rightholders to hundreds of European politicians and decision makers calling for the full and effective implementation of the EU AI Act. Too many AI companies - including Big Tech with AI divisions - are building GenerativeAI off the...more
Pulse Music Group forms publishing partnership with Gabe Simon's Abide By The Vibe
First Collaborative Signings to the JV are Noah Levine and Sam Westhoff PULSE Music Group has formed a music publishing joint venture with songwriter/producer Gabe Simon (Noah Kahan, Dua Lipa, Lana Del Rey) as announced today by PULSE Music Group co-CEOs Scott Cutler and Josh Abraham, and...more
Audiomack Expands Global South Asian Music Offering Through Landmark Partnership with Saregama
Strategic partnership brings thousands of essential Bollywood and regional tracks to global streaming platform Streaming and discovery platform Audiomack has partnered with India's leading music label Saregama, marking a significant expansion of its South Asian music catalog. This strategic alliance adds thousands of Bollywood...more
Statements on the Autumn Budget
UK Music Chief Executive Tom Kiehl said: "The Budget, Labour's first in government for 14 years, is a significant moment as we seek to grow the music industry over the course of this new Parliament. The sector is made up of...more
YolanDa Brown unveiled as Artist Ambassador for Independent Venue Week 2025
The acclaimed saxophonist - and now venue owner - will champion the UK’s annual celebration of independent venues when it returns between 27th January and 2nd February 2025 YolanDa will play a special show, celebrating the music of Bob Marley, at...more
BBC TWO and BBC MUSIC present WHAM!: Last Christmas Unwrapped
This Christmas, in celebration of its 40th anniversary, BBC Two and BBC Music presents WHAM!: Last Christmas Unwrapped – an hour-long celebration from Blink Films and Sony Music Entertainment, in association with Andrew Ridgeley and George Michael Entertainment, of a latter-day Christmas classic,...more
White Label Auction in aid of The BRIT Trust returns on 5 November 2024
Just one week to go to the fifth edition of the world’s leading sale of collectible test pressings Lots ranging from signed Cure, Iggy Pop and The 1975 releases to test pressings from Queen, The Jam, Rolling Stones, The Who, Florence...more
B-Unique confirm renewed publishing deal with songwriter/producer Jon Maguire
B-Unique Music is pleased to announce the extension of its seven-year publishing relationship with renowned songwriter and producer Jon "MAGS" Maguire. The new worldwide deal continues a highly successful partnership that has seen significant achievements and global success. Over the past...more
Daniel Lang promoted to SVP, Global Society Relations and Digital Rights at Warner Chappell Music
Daniel Lang has been promoted to the new role of SVP, Global Society Relations and Digital Rights at Warner Chappell Music, the music publishing arm of Warner Music Group. He will continue to be based in London and report to...more
FAC & MU publish an open letter to the Government and UK live music industry on the "cost of touring crisis"
The Featured Artists Coalition (FAC) and Musicians' Union (MU) have published an open letter to the government and the UK's live music industry in response to the “cost of touring crisis” facing artists and performers. Although evident at all levels...more
Official Charts strike deal with leading jukebox operator NSM Music
The UK Official Singles Chart to appear on thousands of jukeboxes under groundbreaking new partnership The UK’s official music and film chart compiler the Official Charts Company has struck a ground-breaking deal with leading jukebox company NSM Music. The strategic partnership will...more
ESNS expands 2025 line-up with exciting festival and conference highlights
ESNS announces 82 new European acts for 2025 showcase festival, including Antony Szmierek (uk-eng), Martha Da'ro (be), Bnnyhunna (nl), Felix Raphael (de), Grayssoker (fr), Soft Launch (ie), Jasmine.4.t (uk-eng) and Tuulikki Bartosik (ee) amongst others. Also, new panels and speakers...more
THE HEADLINES
Greatest hits albums, once a must purchase, have lost their mojo (see Comment)
Universal reported year-on-year growth (see Business)
Virgin Music Group acquires Outdustry (see Business)
Nina Nesbitt shares the ‘honest truth’ of starting her own record label (see Features)
FAC & MU publish an open letter to the Government and UK live music industry on the "cost of touring crisis" (see News)
‘Responsibly-Trained AI’ gives a Brenda Lee Christmas classic a Spanish makeover (see Digital)
Ditto Music signs a direct deal with TikTok (see Digital)
The future of music festivals is niche and artist-led (see Features)
Impala issues open letter to TikTok (see News)
Navigating the future through music and tech (see Comment)
Black Lives In Music launches Anti-Racism Code Of Conduct (see News)
Distribution platform UnitedMasters announces partnership with TikTok (see Digital)
The industry must examine its treatment of young artists (see Features)
Creative professionals and organisations protest the unlicensed use of creative works to train generative AI models (see News)
Why do we care more about pop stars’ marketing than their music? (see Features)