When They Go Low, We Go High 10 Sep 2018
The European Parliament’s decision not to immediately pass the new EU Copyright Directive in July was seen by many as a major setback. It was defeated by 318 to 278, a margin of 40 votes. This means the proposed legislation now moves forward to a full plenary debate and vote next Wednesday 12 September.
As the music industry faces this pivotal moment, it is worth reflecting how we got here and what we are now facing.
The creative industries as a whole have long argued that embryonic digital legislation passed in the mid 1990s is outdated and simply not fit for purpose. The legislative process is slow at the best of times. Meanwhile, the tech industry “moved fast and broke things,” incurring the wrath of creators whose livelihoods have been upended as a result.
The publication of the draft EU Copyright Directive in late 2016 was an achievement in itself. Not only did the draft legislation address copyright protection and safe harbour loopholes, it also contained provisions concerning fairness and transparency towards creators. Following further debate and lobbying, is even more of an achievement that the key elements of the draft directive remain mostly intact.
The Directive has not been without it’s critics, as is the case with any proposed legislation. Academics, libraries and dignitaries such as Sir Tim Berners-Lee have all put forth concerns. We in the music industry can acknowledge some concerns as understandable even if we believe they are unfounded.
What is not understandable are the thoroughly vile and dishonest tactics deployed during the course of this year, whose objective is to stop the legislation in its tracks at any cost. The scale of this activity reads like set pieces straight out of the Cambridge Analytica playbook.
Some in the music industry have questioned how we fight back given the vast funding involved and the sheer scale of this enterprise. But fight back we must and the actions of those we face only serve to give us greater strength.
As any Jiu-Jitsu grandmaster will tell you: use your opponents’ force against them. In this case, we should call out the deceitful actions from within the tech sector and elsewhere and those actions speak louder than any words.
The Financial Times reported some MEPs received death threats
MEPs were each bombarded with over 60,000 emails from bots
These emails contained identical content according to The Trichordist
The same blog named the domain name from which a large number of these emails originated and its link to a US Inc. entity.
The same tactics have been found on Twitter: multiple bot accounts promoting #SaveOurInternet and similar hashtags
This contrasts to real world protests that only drew a few hundred protestors combined across Europe. The bots did not show up.
These actions must also be viewed against the current backdrop where tech firms have been scrutinised for avoiding responsibility concerning:
Blatantly dishonest content
Content that incites hatred and violence
Little accountability in how such content is disseminated
Minimal transparency in how user data is abused in facilitating all this
Mark Zuckerberg and Jack Dorsey are amongst those tech executives rebuked by lawmakers on both sides of the Atlantic, for failing to take responsibility and failing to act in managing their own platforms. This is reflective of a broader failure that lies at the heart of a misguided and libertarian ideal, that somehow tech firms are exempt from laws and rules that govern the rest of the world.
The music industry and broader creative and media industries are made up of real people, filled with passion and blood pumping through their veins. They compose their own emails, speak to politicians and show up in person.
At the UK Music organized #LoveMusic busking event in London earlier today, artists, executives and even politicians turned out in support. Artists such as Brett Anderson, Ed Harcourt, Dave Rowntree, Madeleina Kay, Newton Faulkner and BASCA Chair Crispin Hunt. In addition a number of cross party British MPs who support the directive including Tom Watson, Nigel Evans and Kevin Brennan were amongst those in attendance.
One has to ask, if those opposing the EU Copyright Directive have such a compelling argument, why do they resort to such deceitful means? If we judge their actions, the arguments of those opposed to the directive hold no legitimacy and the European Parliament should vote in favour of the directive.
Andy Edwards, music manager and consultant
NEWS & PRESS
Internal Promotions Leverage Expertise in Music and Entertainment Sectors Centtrip Music, the music industry specialist division of treasury and international payments expert Centtrip, has announced two new promotions within its senior management team. Simon Liddell has been promoted from his previous position...more
PPL pays out over £39m in latest payment- Over 81,000 members paid- ‘Copyright term extension’ payments are rising ï‚· Strong international payment of £21.5mMusic licensing company PPL has today announced a quarterly payment of £39.2 million.In total over 73,000 performers...more
Atlantic Records UK has announced the promotion of Callum Caulfield to Marketing Director, effective immediately. In this role, he will be responsible for leading the strategic development and execution of campaigns for Atlantic’s rich and diverse roster, home to some...more
Award-winning British singer, songwriter and vocal producer, Michelle Escoffery, has joined the PRS Board as Writer Director. Michelle is celebrated as one of the UK’s most respected songwriters. A member of singing family group, The Escoffery’s, she signed to Atlantic Records...more
Universal Music Publishing Group (UMPG), a leading global publishing company, today announced that rising British pop sensation HRVY has been signed to an exclusive publishing deal. In 2017, HRVY’s debut EP 'Holiday' featuring Redfoo and Stylo G reached No. 2 on...more
The FAC is delighted to announce a very exciting partnership with legendary music instrument maker Roland
The partnership opens a new, collaborative relationship between the FAC and Roland, bringing masterclasses, production & music making expertise, world class facilities and more to our membership in 2019. Roland Corporation is a leading manufacturer and distributor of electronic musical...more
The UK creators association reveals a rebrand as part of its ambitious growth strategy for 2019.Graham Davies continues as Interim CEO, whilst MEP Emma McClarkin and music lawyer Julia Montero join as Independent Directors of the Board. The British Academy of...more
The British Academy of Songwriters, Composers and Authors (BASCA) has announced that Chief Executive Officer Vick Bain is stepping down. In her thirteen years at BASCA Vick held several positions before being appointed CEO in 2012. Following a period of serious ill-health...more
Celeste, one of the most exciting young soul songwriters in Britain, has signed a worldwide deal with Warner/Chappell Music, the music publishing arm of Warner Music Group. The deal comes after news of Celeste’s recent signing to Polydor Records. The...more
New survey reveals boost to diversity among British music industry workforce â€“ but leaders warn more must be done
UK Music today published the results of its 2018 Music Industry Workforce Diversity Survey. UK Music, the umbrella body representing the UK's commercial music industry, today revealed survey findings that show the changing face of Britain's world-leading music business. The survey, which...more
Moira Stuart, one of the nation’s most popular and respected television and radio broadcasters, is joining Classic FM next year as the station’s new presenter.Starting in February, Stuart will become Classic FM’s morning news presenter, on air every weekday from 6.00am...more
Brit starlet and America's Got Talent finalist Courtney Hadwin signs recording and publishing deal with Syco Music and Arista Records
Courtney Hadwin has signed a long-term recording contract with Syco Music in partnership with Arista Records in the US. The 14-year-old from Hartlepool, Northern England rose to fame in the US after she starred in this year's series of America's Got Talent on...more
In our new borderless Global music streaming market, Africa is seen by many industry analysts as the next region to drive user growth. LyricFind, the world's largest lyric licensing company, is excited to further extend their lead with published content, by...more
On December 7th and 12th, the Diet of Japan and the European Parliament both held their respective votes in favour of ratification of the EU-Japan trade agreement. As representatives of the recording industry in Japan and worldwide, we welcome the...more
Bauer Media has signed Dawn French as the station voice of national radio brand – Greatest Hits Radio. The station will play the biggest songs of the 70s, 80s and 90s, listeners will discover an upbeat, authentic, fun and entertaining formatwhere the ‘Good Times Sound...more
Record labels association the BPI and South Wales Police recently collaborated over a four-year period to close down a major counterfeit operation specialising in Northern Soul records.Last month, on 30th November 2018 at Newport Crown Court four defendants: Alan Godfrey,...more
On December 13th, Soundation launches a new browser-based studio and visual identity across all channels in cooperation with design agency Kurppa Hosk. Apart from the studio’s new UI, the studio engine also gains a +300% performance improvement as a result...more
The UK’s leading music therapy charity Nordoff Robbins are delighted to announce the official launch of a brand-new partnership with Rock Choir, which will see both organisations working together to reach even more people with the life-changing power of music...more
After twelve years at the helm of The Worldwide Independent Network (WIN), the global forum for the professional independent music industry, Alison Wenham is stepping down as Chief Executive of the organisation. Prior to joining WIN full time in 2016 Alison...more
Global Underground set to release latest edition in its city album series with GU42: Patrice BÃ¤umel - Berlin next March
Global Underground presents the latest edition in its signature city album series with GU42: Patrice Bäumel - Berlin, due for release on Friday 29th March 2019. The album, which follows the last Global Underground city series installments by Solomun, and...more
Kacey Musgraves, George Ezra and Andy C presented awards to celebrate first time achievements at the SSE Arena, Wembley
Awards were recently presented to CMA winner Kacey Musgraves, singer-song writer George Ezra and drum’n’bass legend Andy C for a series of monumental firsts at The SSE Arena, Wembley. American country music singer-songwriter Kacey Musgraves was presented an award for her...more
Pivotal new fund for independent music creators offers nearly £60k of holistic support across creative, wellbeing and business Help Musicians UK (HMUK) today celebrated the first 22 music creators who have received funding from the charity's first ever Do it Differently Fund – which...more
Flohio, Ms Banks, Novelist, Big Zuu and more: Behind the scenes of the first ever grime and rap songwriting camp
Some of the biggest talent in UK grime and rap came together this week, for a first-of-its-kind songwriting camp. Marking the end of 2018, a year that saw Godfather of Grime, Wiley, receive an MBE for services to music, PRS for Music and ASCAP,...more
As Commission, Parliament and Council meet in Strasbourg to negotiate the Copyright Directive, a broad coalition of rightholders have called for them to remember the original objective of the legislation, which is to correct the distortion of the digital marketplace caused...more
Little Mix, BTS, The 1975, Charli XCX, HRVY and a Hollywood All-Star line-up including Hailee Steinfeld, John Cena, Emma Stone and Benedict Cumberbatch are set to host their own hour long show on BBC Radio 1 this Christmas Day with...more
Robert Ashcroft, Chief Executive of PRS for Music said: “I would like to congratulate Paul on his appointment and look forward to working with him in his new capacity as Chief Executive of the MPA Group of Companies. Paul has given 22 years...more
Following Massive Success of "Words I Never Said", Ella Vos Takes Career to Next Level with AWAL AWAL, Kobalt's recording company, today announced a worldwide recordings deal with Los Angeles-based singer, songwriter and visual artist, Ella Vos. The AWAL recordings deal...more
Justin Tranter and Katie Vinten partner withÂ Warner Bros. Records for launch of new label, Facet Records
Vinten Will Also Serve as A&R Consultant to Warner Bros. and Warner/Chappell Music Warner Bros. Records (WBR) today announced that the company has partnered with award-winning songwriter Justin Tranter and Katie Vinten, most recently Co-Head of A&R for Warner/Chappell Music, to...more
Sony/ATV Music Publishing has signed a worldwide deal with Grammy-nominated singer and songwriter Ella Mai whose breakthrough hit “Boo’d Up” is one of the biggest singles of the year. The award-winning song climbed to No. 5 on the Billboard Hot 100,...more
BASCA plans new strategy; makes appointments. (see News)
Global recorded music revenues forecast to show increase of 8.2% in 2018. (see Analysis)
Ed Sheeran scores highest gross for a touring artist in a single year. (see News)
CEO Vick Bain leaves BASCA. (see Business)
BPI to push for royalties from US radio plays in future trade agreement. (see News)
Music Industry Workforce Diversity Survey shows progress, but more to be done. (see News)
Industry groups back calls for the European Parliament to "correct the distortion of the digital marketplace". (see News)
Alison Wenham to step down from WIN. (see News)
Tencent ends first day trading up 8.6%; looks to subscription model. (see Business, Digital)
Paul Clements appointed CEO of The MPA Group. (see News)
Final ruling on the Blurred Lines case. (see News)
Tencent Music prices shares at bottom of targeted range. (see Business)
Industry bodies and artists sign letter calling on the Government for an alternative to Brexit. (see News)
Government commits £2m to fund the ongoing Get it Right anti-piracy campaign. (see News)
Ed Sheeran's Shape of You becomes the first track to reach 2bn Spotify streams. (see News)
Apple acquires Platoon. (see Business)
BBC's Sound of 2019 longlist announced. (see News)
Grammy awards nominations announced. (see News)