Record Industry Wins Double Landmark UK Court Victory In New Cyberlocker and Stream Ripping Piracy Cases 25 Feb 2021
Following an online hearing, the High Court has ruled that cyberlocker and stream ripping sites, and a stream ripping app, infringe UK copyright
The High Court has ordered internet companies to block them
The two rulings benefit artists, songwriters, music publishers and record companies who suffer annual piracy losses of £200 million
The BPI calls on Government to take stronger measures to require platforms to tackle piracy and boost the streaming economy
Record labels association the BPI has today won two significant new piracy cases, brought by major and independent record companies, confirming for the first time that cyberlockers and stream rippers – and those who use them – break the law.
The cases were dealt with following an online hearing by Mr Justice Miles at London’s High Court, who ruled that the operators and users of the websites use the services of internet companies (ISPs) to infringe copyright and that therefore the ISPs should block access to them. The infringing uses included providing or linking to a downloadable stream ripping app.
The two judgments are significant developments and benefit the whole music industry – artists, songwriters, music publishers and record companies large and small, as well as legitimate music streaming services. Stream ripping and cyberlockers are the music industry’s current biggest piracy threats. They are responsible for part of the £200 million a year that is illegally ripped out of the music industry ecosystem and which could otherwise be helping to boost the legal music streaming economy.
The landmark group litigation represents a hard-won legal victory in the ongoing fight against music piracy. The BPI has been developing the cases for two years, with 3,000 pages of evidence and months of negotiations with the UK’s six biggest ISPs – BT, EE, PlusNet, Sky, TalkTalk and Virgin Media.
The Court heard the industry’s legal arguments on 3rd February 2021 in an online hearing due to the pandemic. The cases were brought in relation to a major cyberlocker ‘Nitroflare’ and a number of stream ripping sites including two of the world’s biggest, ‘Flvto’ and ‘2Conv’. Some of these sites provided or linked to the downloadable app, ‘MP3 Studio’. Together these sites attract over a billion visits a year worldwide, and tens of millions a year from the UK alone.
Stream ripping sites like ‘Flvto’ are so problematic that they appear on the US Government’s ‘Notorious Markets List’ and on the European Commission’s ‘Counterfeit and Piracy Watch List’. When a user accesses an illegal stream ripping site, or downloads and uses a stream ripping app, a song is ripped from services like YouTube (or in some cases social media sites such as Facebook and Instagram) and downloaded, enabling the user to listen to the music over and over again illegally, without any payment to the songwriters, performers, music publishers and record companies who create and invest in that music. The operators of the illegal stream ripping sites make millions of pounds a year from advertising in the UK alone, but do not share a penny with the creators of the music they are exploiting.
As to cyberlockers, sites like Nitroflare are deliberately designed to encourage and reward users to upload music and other valuable copyright material, and illegally share links to it with others who can then illegally download it. Mr Justice Miles found that although music only represents around 10% of all files available on Nitroflare, the site warranted being blocked because it actively encouraged illegal sharing and it was highly unlikely that the site was being used for legitimate storage on a significant scale. The site also rewards those who illegally share music and penalises those who do not share by deleting their files.
The High Court’s decision also comes as a Parliamentary Select Committee inquiry is looking intoEconomics of Music Streaming, including the impact that piracy is having.
Legal music streaming now accounts for 80% of music consumption in the UK and is helping the industry return to growth after years of piracy-driven decline. But revenues have still not recovered to their pre-piracy levels and much more still needs to be done to help protect the music industry ecosystem and creators.
Although the BPI’s latest two cases are powerful tools to help protect the music industry from unacceptably high levels of online piracy, they are not silver bullets. That is why in its response to the Parliamentary inquiry, the BPI has called on Government to continue to do more to help reduce piracy and to grow the value of the legal streaming market for the benefit of the whole industry, in particular (1) by introducing a ‘duty of care’ for online platforms who use music in their business models; (2) by preventing such platforms misusing ‘safe harbour’ provisions to underpay for the music they use; (3) by introducing a statutory damages regime in the UK to deter illegal sites and (4) by introducing faster and more affordable ways for rightsholders to obtain website blocking orders against illegal sites.
The record industry continues to invest heavily in anti-piracy for the benefit of the wider music community. It started to take action against illegal streaming sites in 2017 when it shut down YouTube-mp3, the world’s biggest stream ripper at the time. The BPI has also been working with search engines to have stream ripper links demoted and delisted from search results, and with YouTube to prohibit ‘how to’ piracy tutorial videos.
The BPI’s two latest legal actions were group litigation cases by major label and independent record companies in a representative capacity on behalf of the members of BPI and PPL (Phonographic Performance Limited).
They were brought under section 97A of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 against the six Defendant ISPs (BT, EE, PlusNet, Sky, TalkTalk and Virgin Media), who did not attend the hearing because, following negotiations with BPI, they agreed ultimately not to oppose the case and to comply with the Court’s decision.
In terms of usage, the BPI has today reviewed updated data for the period January 2018 - December 2020 showing that ‘Nitroflare’, the cyberlocker to be blocked, has received an average of 3.5 million annual UK visits over that three year period.
There are four currently active stream ripping sites to be blocked, varying in popularity – namely ‘Flvto’ (with an average 58 million annual UK visits over the last three years), ‘2Conv’ (25 million annual UK visits), ‘Flv2mp3’ (1.7 million annual UK visits) and ‘H2Converter’ (700,000 annual UK visits), plus the downloadable app provider ‘MP3 Studio’ (1.2 million annual UK visits).
Geoff Taylor, BPI’s Chief Executive said:
“Illegal sites, including stream rippers and cyberlockers, rip hundreds of millions of pounds from the music economy in the UK every year and hold back the growth of the UK’s legal streaming market. The BPI takes action on multiple fronts for labels and artists to ensure that platforms that use music pay fairly, but we would like Government to set a clear duty of care on digital platforms to prevent illegal content appearing on their services, and make it simpler, cheaper and faster for creators to take action against the illegal use of their work. This can make the UK the best country in the world to invest in music and to be a music fan.”
Kiaron Whitehead, BPI General Counsel responsible for the UK litigation said:
“The High Court has confirmed what we all believed, namely that the operators and users of these egregious cyberlocker and stream ripping sites – together with the associated stream ripping app – infringe copyright in multiple ways and should be blocked in the UK. The illegal sites have more visits to them than even global brand websites like Coca-Cola and McDonalds, and they deprive those who create and invest in music from their rightful rewards. These two new judgments are important both legally and practically. They are not a silver bullet, but they develop existing European law and represent a significant step forwards in copyright law in the UK. We are grateful to the High Court in dealing with this group litigation so efficiently in an online hearing. The BPI will be taking further actions following these judgments.”
Amanda Solloway, Minister for Intellectual Property said:
“This result is good news for artists and performers, and I am grateful to BPI for its defence of our country’s intellectual property laws. These ‘stream ripping’ providers steal hundreds of millions of pounds which should be going to our world-renowned music industry. The Government will continue working closely with the music industry to combat piracy, protect jobs and maintain one of the strongest intellectual property frameworks in the world.”
Detective Constable Abdun Noor, The City of London Police’s Intellectual Property Crime Unit (PIPCU) said:
“Intellectual property crime causes significant harm. The BPI’s new High Court stream ripping and cyberlocker judgments assist the work we do nationally and internationally as the Police Intellectual Property Crime Unit, together with our law enforcement partners, to tackle IP crime. Intellectual property crime is not a victimless crime: the revenue lost through copyright infringement means people in the industry losing their jobs.”
Gee Davy, COO and Head of Legal & Business Affairs, Association of Independent Music (AIM) said:
“These judgments are not only a win for the independent music businesses named in the cases but the whole music ecosystem and AIM congratulates BPI on their expert handling of these cases. Getting music from illegitimate sites and services drives down the value of music and the money available to pay musicians and fund creativity. We hope that these judgments will serve as a strong deterrent to other illegitimate cyberlockers and stream rippers and raise awareness of legitimate ways to enjoy great music.”
NEWS & PRESS
Youth climate groups launch â€˜Climate Liveâ€™ with 24 hours of global live music streams on April 24
Declan McKenna to perform in the UKHIGHLIGHTS FROM ACROSS THE WORLD INCLUDE: MILKY CHANCE | LEEPA | ANLY | LIA PAPPAS-KEMPS | ELI ALMIC |SCOTT HELMAN | LUNA LI | ANY GABRIELLY (SPEAKER) & MORE CLIMATE LIVE 16 OCTOBER 2021 https://www.climatelive.org Climate Live today reveals...more
FIRST SINGLE: LEFTWING : KODY - ‘DEEPER’ ft. DARLA JADE Watch/Listen to ‘Deeper’ HERE Today (23rd April), new record label 21NHG launches with their first release, Leftwing : Kody - ‘Deeper’ ft Darla Jade, available now across all DSPs. 21NHG is a dedicated dance...more
‘Behind The Counter’ video series to spotlight the UK’s independent record shops in special series re-launch The 12-part video series will launch on the 27th April in the run up to this year’s Record Store Day Drops‘Behind The Counter’ is presented by Record Store Day and...more
Driift, the pioneering livestream business behind acclaimed ticketed online shows for artists including Niall Horan, Nick Cave, Biffy Clyro, Andrea Bocelli, Kylie Minogue, Dermot Kennedy, Courtney Barnett, Laura Marling and Birdy is delighted to announce the appointment of Sasha Duncan...more
Audiomack partners with MTN to bring music streaming to over 76 million subscribers at zero data cost
The partnership will see MTN subscribers gain free access to Audiomack’s streaming service via their mobile devices on weekly and monthly subscriptions Audiomack has partnered with MTN Nigeria (www.MTNonline.com) to unveil the Audiomack+MTN Data Bundle program (www.MTN.tc.Audiomack.com), which offers MTN...more
Umbrella organisation continues to expand with formation of sub-committees Live music Industry Venues & Entertainment (LIVE) has appointed Chris Carey to the role of Chief Economist, as the live music industry trade organisation continues to grow, establishing a series of specialist...more
Spotify has released its third mint Singles, a companion to its flagship Dance playlist, mint, and a spin-off of the popular Spotify Singles series. The release is a Spotify-exclusive brand-new original song by Aluna ft. Michael Brun & Alicai Harley,...more
The 2021 BRIT Awards ceremony will go ahead with a live audience as the latest addition to the government’s Events Research Programme, which looks at how venues can restart large events and welcome crowds back safely this summer. The BRIT Awards...more
Today marks the launch of Radio 1 Relax, a brand new 24-hour stream to help listeners unwind on BBC Sounds. The new stream will launch with an 11-hour simulcast across Radio 1 and Radio 1 Relax beginning at 5pm BST today...more
Labyrinth Announces Seven 'Sessions Seriesâ€™ Shows across London w/ Axel Boman, Gerd Janson, Perel and Todd Terje + more
The shows will take place across some of London’s best venues including Loft Studios, Village Underground and The Cause Labyrinth Sessions is a series of shows that allow artists to dig deep into their record collection, showcase the full range of their...more
GOAT GIRL, Mystry, Santino Le Saint and Arborist among the latest artists to receive support from PRS Foundationâ€™s PPL Momentum Music Fund
Applications for the next round are open now – deadline for submissions is 24th May 2021 at 6pm PRS Foundation, the UK’s leading charitable funder of new music and talent development, together with PPL, Creative Wales, Arts Council of Northern Ireland, Invest Northern...more
Swallow Events acquire the use of rapid testing provisions for forthcoming events/festivals, including Picnic Records, Campo Sancho Festival and Access the Music Festival
With a sensitivity of 97.1% and a specificity of 99.6%. With pricing starts from a little as £8 per test kit. The individually packaged test is imminently due to receive self-testing approval in the form of UK MHRA Emergency use (it is the second...more
Available to purchase on OpenSea for Ξ0.2 on Friday 23rd April, 10:00 BST 220 Kid and Billen Ted are the brains behind viral TikTok hit The Wellerman Remix Proceeds from sales will support the Royal National Lifeboat Institution (RNLI) and 220 Kid Scholarship...more
Leading independent digital music distributor TuneCore, has partnered with Point Blank Music School and youth charity, The Prince’s Trust to create a week-long programme for young people looking to join the music industry. Get Started in the Music Industry runs...more
First episode features BRITs Rising Star winner Griff and broadcaster Jordan North Exclusive premiere tomorrow night on the Amazon Music UK Twitch channel The BRIT Awards with Mastercard 2021Tuesday May 11th 2021 – at The O2 arena on ITV and ITV Hub The BRIT Awards...more
Music is a reliable source of comfort for consumers, who are turning to music as they spend more time inside: 75% of the general population in France engages with music, with 91% of music listeners saying they listen to it at home. Among total respondents, 51% say...more
Clara Amfo has been named as the new host of BBC Radio 1’s flagship new music show, Radio 1’s Future Sounds (Monday – Thursday, 6 – 8pm), with Rickie, Melvin and Charlie to take on Radio 1’s iconic Live Lounge...more
· New agreement brings Brazilian fans the best of music, podcast and video entertainment · The deal positions Deezer as the optimal global audio partner for entertainment brands Deezer, the global audio streaming service, and Globoplay, the largest Brazilian video streaming provider...more
Warner Chappell Music, in partnership with Dr. Dre’s Hard Workin’ Black Folks, has entered into a worldwide administration agreement with four-time Grammy Award-winning songwriter, rapper, singer, producer, director and multi-instrumentalist Anderson .Paak. His latest project brings .Paak together with fellow Warner...more
Martin Garrix and Maejor have signed with STMPD RCRDS/Hollywood Records (Disney Music Group) for their collaborative project AREA21. The music of AREA21 follows a story arc of two alien travelers who are tripping through the cosmos spreading a message of...more
Beatchain and Better Noise Music Partner for New Marketing Initiative to Amplify Fan Engagement Opportunities
Music marketing and distribution platform Beatchain announces a new partnership with leading independent record label and global artist development company Better Noise Music, sparking an initiative that will better help artists and listeners connect using fan engagement data. The strategic...more
Brand new documentary The Battle for Britney: Fans, Cash and a Conservatorship will drop on BBC iPlayer on Saturday 1 May, with a BBC Two broadcast to follow on Wednesday 5May at 9pm BST. This 1x60 film will seek to uncover...more
ATC Live are delighted to welcome David "Skully" Sullivan-Kaplan into the company. A hugely respected agent, Skully joins from United Talent Agency (UTA) and brings with him a diverse and acclaimed artist roster including Larkin Poe, Steel Pulse, Polica, Gentleman's Dub...more
UK Music Urges Music Industry To Break Down Employment Barriers As Survey Reveals 1 in 5 Disabled People Face Discrimination At Work
UK Music is calling on music industry leaders to ensure disabled people and people with long term health conditions can realise their dreams by removing potential barriers to job opportunities. The call comes as UK Music published new findings from its...more
With more in-home engagement, consumers are connecting with music in many ways: 86% of the general population in Spain engages with music, with 62% saying music is important/extremely important to them, followed by music videos (33%) and live streamed/virtual music events (30%) 94% of music listeners...more
Lyric Financial, the company that pioneered royalty-based financing for the global music community, is announcing it has crossed $100 million mark in financing provided to its clients. From automated advances for independent artists and labels to creatively structured facilities for...more
BandLab, the mobile-first music creation and sharing platform, has caught up to GarageBand in mobile downloads, according to data from SensorTower. The app, available for Android and iOS, was installed more than 1.2 million times in March 2021 according to...more
Major updates to Apple Podcasts make discovering and enjoying podcasts better than ever before Apple today unveiled Apple Podcasts Subscriptions, a global marketplace for listeners to discover premium subscriptions offered by their favourite creators alongside millions of free shows on Apple Podcasts. Starting...more
Warner Music (WM) Asia has announced a deal that will make it the exclusive music partner to gaming platform Esports Player League (ESPL). The deal will allow ESPL to embed Warner Music songs into its platform and drive awareness of...more
Universal report strong Q1 figures (see Business)
Summer festivals on the brink without insurance (see News, Features)
BRIT Awards to host audience of 4,000 without social distancing (see News)
Music NFT market update (see Analysis)
Survey of the recorded and publishing sectors reveals changes in global market share (see Analysis)
Artists call on the PM to put the value of music back "in the hands of music makers" (see News)
Shakeup to Radio 1's schedule (see Media)
Facebook to deepen relationship with Spotify (see Digital)
Initiatives announced ahead of Earth Day (see News)
Musiio's AI analyses viral songs to seek useful patterns (see Analysis)
Rebalancing the Song Economy report suggests "payment for writers is dysfunctional at best" (see Analysis, Features)
Apple Music’s payment rate for artists and labels is at least double what Spotify pays artists/Also: Why it's misleading to say that (see Digital)
Penske Media to acquire 50% stake in SxSW (see Business)
The future of how we’ll consume music (see Features)
Warner and Spotify announce podcast partnership (see Digital)
Rap and Hip Hop accounted for 22% of all UK singles consumption in 2020 (see Analysis)
Spotify enables album downloads; partners with virtual events companies (see Digital)
Time running out for some summer festivals (see News)
Spotify officially announces Car Thing (see Digital)
How Tim Burgess’ Twitter Listening Party lifted fans during lockdown (see Features)
Nightclub industry fears for its post-Covid future (see Features)
Dance music has thrived on Spotify during lockdown (see Digital)
Streaming may have saved the industry, but does it now need reform itself? (see Features)