Andy Edwards explores the facts and figures behind the Arts Council v Music Business debate 13 Apr 2018
The role of the Arts Council is once again in the headlines. This week, leading figures representing the music industry locked horns with senior opera figures over Arts Council funding.
UK Music CEO Michael Dugher branded Arts Council England (ACE) “too posh for pop”, pointing out that 62% of ACE’s National Portfolio goes to opera and a further 23% goes to classical music. In contrast, only 8% goes to popular music and 7% to other genres (including jazz, folk, etc).
Hitting back in The Daily Telegraph, Michael Volpe General Director of Holland Park Opera, responded “I’ve been hearing the word ‘posh’ in relation to opera for 30 years. Very few people in opera are posh - certainly not the performers”, although Volpe conceded in the same piece “Opera companies get a lot of money, perhaps more than they ought to, and that’s an ongoing argument.”
ACE has £1.45 billion of public funds and £860 million National Lottery funds to distribute over the next four years. Of the £368 million allocated to music, opera will receive £229 million, classical £85 million and pop £27 million.
The debate is especially timely because ACE has initiated a public conversation to help inform its strategy for the next 10 years. Given the music industry is only just returning to growth having suffered 15 years of decline, a lot is at stake. A barrier to that discussion is a fundamental misunderstanding between both sides.
Some might argue the opera world, and the arts establishment as a whole, seem to look down on the music industry or, perhaps, hold the view that it is less deserving. Many in the music industry consider opera an irrelevance and an extravagance.
The reality is the music industry is vastly more complex, diverse and challenging than is often understood. It is also a reality that opera is accessible through multi-tiered ticket pricing and many opera companies are addressing their own diversity issues.
What are the key issues? How can both sides better understand one another and what does a satisfactory outcome look like?
THE FUNDING IMBALANCE
Not only is there a huge imbalance towards opera, but there is also a disproportionate amount awarded to the Royal Opera House in London specifically. During 2016 alone, the ROH received £28 million in Arts Council funding, which represents 20% of the ROH’s total income for that year. The remainder is made up of box office receipts, commercial income and other fundraising. This includes various charitable trusts and corporate backers such as Goldman Sachs.
By way of comparison, UK Sport fulfils a similar function to the Arts Council and also relies on a combination of public money and lottery funding. It is worth noting the spread of investment across the Olympic disciplines is much more even. Of the £265 million earmarked for the Tokyo Olympic cycle, rowing receives the most with £32 million, followed by athletics (£27m), sailing (£26m), cycling (£26) and swimming (£22m). Although medals success and underlying costs are a factor, the distribution of funds is far more even when compared to arts funding for music. Equestrian was further down the list with £15m, but imagine the uproar if Equestrian took 60% of available funding at the expense of other medal winning sports.
It is hard to see how the imbalance between opera, classical and other forms of music can be justified. Moreover, if funding were to be taken away from opera and distributed more broadly, how detrimental would that be? Supposing ACE funding for the Royal Opera House is cut in half, that would represent a 10% cut in its overall income. Can the ROH be challenged to go without or make up that funding elsewhere?
MOMENTUM MUSIC FUND – A CASE FOR GRANT FUNDING
In 2013, Arts Council England supported the launch of the Momentum Music Fund, administered by the PRS Foundation. Momentum was aimed at artists existing outside the major label system, unsigned or signed to an independent, and who could demonstrable a case for £5-15,000 worth of funding to give their careers tangible momentum at a crucial point.
The scheme has been a great success. Over 270 artists have been supported by Momentum and for every £1 invested £7.46 has been generated. Recipients are truly diverse covering a broad spread of genres with a strong BAME representation, making up 49% of grantees.
Over 3,800 artists have applied for Momentum funding since its inception. Five years after its launch demand and impact has never been greater. The recently published outline of Government's creative industries sector deal, which encourages partnerships between government and industry, mentions the Momentum Fund as an example of good practice.
The frustration is that despite this clear proof of concept, including the quality and diversity of the artists supported and the match funding & income it has leveraged there appears to be little appetite from the Arts Council to continue its involvement in such schemes.
ATTITUDES TO INVESTMENT NEED TO CHANGE
A key challenge is how the music industry is perceived and how it perceives itself.
Culturally, a disproportionate level of attention is afforded to a tiny minority of major artists earning vast sums at the expense of the majority who do not. This contributes to long held assumptions within the arts establishment, government and the wider public that all paths through the music industry are paved with gold. They are not.
Within the industry itself, there has been a tradition of self-reliance. Labels and publishers, especially, pride themselves on their investment in new music. This is very true, but that investment only comes at a certain stage. Leading up to that point, artists and their managers typically funded themselves. Prior to the launch of Momentum, grant type funding for artists was very rarely considered as an option.
Attitudes are very different when it comes to sport. Even world-class athletes such as Mo Farah continue to receive grant funding from Sport UK. In Farah’s case, this is despite considerable endorsement income and a personal net worth rumoured to be £4 million. Grant type funding in sport began in the late 90s. Twenty years later, Great Britain can look back on Olympic glory over the past three Olympic cycles in Beijing, London and Rio across a range of sports. This was no coincidence.
THE ROAD AHEAD
Leading up to the publication of the government’s Industrial Strategy (Creative Industries Sector Deal) earlier this year, there was much debate about funding. Early funding gaps were evident across the creative sector and especially so in music.
For a new artist, releasing music has never been easier: the major streaming platforms are readily accessible to any artist. The principle sources of investment remain labels and publishers although other self-release options such as Seed EIS are available. What has changed is the time it takes to reach that level. A new artist may take several years funding their own releases and live shows during that time. Few new artists have the means to do this, especially those from less affluent backgrounds. This has created very real roadblocks in the talent pipeline as the industry has shifted from CD to download to streaming.
There is a clear deficiency in investment at the seed/ angel level. Unlike the tech world, there are very few mechanisms providing a return to the early stage investor while safeguarding the artist. An artist’s business structure, especially at an early stage, can be fluid and may not have all IP and activities sitting in one entity. Very few new artists could be considered “investment ready” in a traditional sense.
This is why grant funding is so important. It does not require equity stakes or convertible loans. It is simple and when targeted correctly, as Momentum has proven, can be highly effective. Grant funding can play a central role in growing a sustainable talent pipeline that fits the streaming age that is now upon us and ensure the industry picks more winners.
The disproportionate level of Arts Council funds devoted to opera does not seem fair or sustainable and it would seem this is recognized even within the world of opera. Meanwhile, the music industry has proven that grant funding can provide a significant boost to more popular genres and sustain a diverse pipeline of creative talent that works in tandem with existing commercial models. Making the numbers work is a bigger question, but there would seem to be a clear imperative to develop a fairer and more balanced approach to Arts Council funding for music.
NEWS & PRESS
2025 Mercury Prize moves to Newcastle
Newcastle Upon Tyne to host first ever Mercury Prize outside of London 2025 ‘Albums of the Year’ Shortlist announced 10th September Award Show to take place at Utilita Arena, Newcastle on 16th October and will be broadcast across BBC platforms All tickets available...more
Andrew Spencer named Chief Operating Officer of AEG Presents Europe
Industry Veteran and Current Chief Commercial Officer at Frontier Touring to Lead European Operations for Live Entertainment Company AEG Presents, a leader in live entertainment, announced today that Andrew Spencer has been named Chief Operating Officer (COO) of AEG Presents Europe....more
Free Party: A Folk History
A DOCUMENTARY BY AWARD-WINNING DIRECTOR AARON TRINDERFREE PARTY: A FOLK HISTORY THE UNTOLD STORY OF HOW RAVE CULTURE SHOOK THE SYSTEM AND SPARKED A GLOBAL REVOLUTION FEATURING SPIRAL TRIBE, BEDLAM, CIRCUS WARP, DiY SOUND SYSTEM, YOUTH (KILLING JOKE), COLIN DALE, CHARLIE HALL...more
Bloc Party to be honoured with Ivor Novello Award for Outstanding Song Collection
IN CELEBRATION OF THE BAND’S EXCEPTIONAL SONGWRITING PROWESS ACROSS A PROLIFIC 25 YEAR CAREER The original four members of Bloc Party will receive the award at the 70th edition of the world’s biggest and most prestigious celebration of songwriters and screen composers,...more
BPI In Tune with Sound City
Sound City hosted the first BPI In Tune with Tomorrow event outside of London Headline interview with Warner Music COO Isabel Garvey setting the scene ahead of a breadth of expert panels drawn from the music ecosystem, each exploring different aspects...more
Warner Music Group unveils WMG Pulse, giving artists and songwriters instant access to real-time insights
Built by WMG’s in-House Tech Experts, App Aggregates Data Across All Major DSPs and Social Media Platform in Beta with 100+ Artists and Songwriters Click HERE for Demo Warner Music Group (NASDAQ: WMG) today announced the beta launch of WMG Pulse, a powerful new platform that...more
AIP to launch UK promoter diversity database
Contributions needed from the sector for pioneering resource. The Association of Independent Promoters (AIP) is calling for contributions to a growing diversity database that will define the spectrum of live music promoters in the UK today. The database will be launched in...more
AIF partners with Stantec to launch Noise Helpline for festival promoters
Santec to host webinar on mysteries and myths around festival noise. The Association of Independent Festivals (AIF) has partnered with Stantec (formerly Hydrock) to launch a new noise helpline for festival promoters. The helpline will be run by Santec and made available...more
Legendary Blue Note Jazz Club granted licence to open their first UK club in London
Today (7th May) the iconic Blue Note Jazz Club is proud to announce they have been granted a licence to open their first UK club. Set within the basement of the St Martins Lane hotel in Covent Garden, the licence...more
Amazon Music returns to exclusively livestream Primavera Sound Barcelona
Music fans will be able to enjoy the festival from 5th – 7th June from anywhere in the world Audiences will be able to tune in via the Amazon Music channels on Twitch and Prime Video Click HERE for streaming details This spring, Amazon Music will return...more
The Dark Arts of preserving Welsh musical heritage in the digital age
Digital agency, Dark Arts, is harnessing the power of AI to preserve and enhance the digital visibility of culturally significant Welsh music catalogues that are at risk of being lost in today’s algorithm-driven era, where engagement and revenue are dependent...more
Concord Music Publishing signs singer-songwriter Grace Tyler
Today, Concord Music Publishing announced the signing of singer-songwriter Grace Tyler in her first publishing deal. The worldwide publishing deal, effective immediately, includes Tyler’s catalog and her upcoming releases. Originally from Frisco, Texas, Grace Tyler attended Belmont University, honing her craft and working with multi-platinum singer-songwriter...more
The MMF and YouTube Music unveil Accelerator's class of 2025
“Accelerator empowers the industry’s preeminent talent developers to do what they do best - develop talent.” 18 talented independent music managers join the 7th edition of our groundbreaking funding and training programme All will receive grants of £10,000, alongside an...more
Italian Performance Rights Collecting SCF closes its 2024 with total distributions of over 51 million euros
The collecting drives the growth: Italy in global Top Ten 2024 confirms the growth trend for performance rights in Italy: this is demonstrated by the overall data of SCF, the leading collecting society in the sector that in the last year...more
Armada Music Signs Joint Venture Deal with Techno Visionary Joris Voorn
Dutch techno pioneer Joris Voorn has confirmed the release of his highly anticipated new album, set to drop this July—marking his first major project in collaboration with Armada Music Armada Music, the biggest independent dance music label in the world, is...more
BRIDGE initiative to strengthen the independents' position in the digital ecosystem across markets
Artists working with record labels have more listeners and income on digital platforms. Low profitability of streaming and high dependence on live performances are challenges to be addressed. Professionalization, industry events and trade associations are key to the development of the Latin...more
Creative industries and growth boosted with new UK-India cultural agreement
UK's arts and culture, creative industries, tourism and sport sectors are set to benefit from a major new cooperation agreement with India Culture Secretary leading a delegation of cultural leaders and UK institutions to Mumbai and New Delhi this week Agreement to...more
NTIA Welcomes Bluenote License Decision but Questions Police's Role in Defining Culture
Night Time Industries Association (NTIA), has welcomed the decision to grant a license to the Bluenote Jazz venue in London, following a highly contested process. However, the case has sparked significant concern over the growing influence of policing in cultural...more
Create Music Group Acquires Independent Label Monstercat Expanding Global Reach in Electronic Music and Gaming
Create Music Group (“CMG”), the world’s leading platform for iconic music, announced today that it has acquired Monstercat, one of the most influential independent electronic music record labels in the world. The deal marks a strategic addition to Create’s growing...more
Downtown's CD Baby Appoints Industry Veterans Sean Hallarman and Craig May to Lead Product and Artist Development
In addition to new appointments, executives Jean Mischler and Whitney Thomas step into expanded roles across marketing, revenue, finance, and business operations CD Baby, Downtown Music’s artist direct distribution and music services platform, today announced the appointment of Sean Hallarman as...more
BBC announces programming to mark 40 years since Live Aid
This July, BBC Two and Radio 2 will mark the 40th anniversary of Live Aid, which took place on Saturday 13th July 1985. BBC Two and BBC iPlayer broadcasts Live Aid at 40, which reveals the behind-the-scenes story of the 1985 concert that brought the...more
Alison Goldfrapp launches own record label A.G Records
New album, Flux, will be released in partnership with Absolute Label Services on August 15. “If you’re lucky enough to have the option, owning your own masters feels like a no-brainer!” - Alison Goldfrapp Electronic pop star Alison Goldfrapp is set to...more
Integrity First: Merlin Joins Music Fights Fraud Alliance to Protect the Music Ecosystem
Merlin, the digital music licensing partner for the world’s leading independent labels and distributors, announced today that it has joined the Music Fights Fraud Alliance (MFFA), the industry’s united front against streaming fraud and illegitimate activity. By contributing to the goals...more
BBC Radio 6 Music announces spring and summer programming
Today, BBC Radio 6 Music reveals a range of upcoming programmes coming to the station this month and beyond. Early June sees the return of Mary Anne Hobbs to 6 Music, who will present a brand new show on Sundays, 6-8pm,...more
Data Bill amendments: BPI comment
BPI Chief Strategy Officer Sophie Jones said: "While these amendments may be welcome in acknowledging the complexity and time needed to fully consider some of the most damaging aspects of the Government's proposals, they should not be taken as a gain for the creative...more
LA Sync Mission 2025 announced for 9th – 13th June
This year's LA Sync Mission, organised jointly by the BPI, MPA and the UK's Department for Business and Trade (DBT), will take place between 9th – 13th June 2025. The event founded to create global opportunities for British sync and to grow UK music exports will be...more
Watford Colosseum confirms first artists for reopening season
AEG Presents newest venue will stage its inaugural show on August 29th AEG Presents announced today (Friday May 2nd) the first artists to perform as part of Watford Colosseum’s reopening season beginning with a show from iconic band Ocean Colour Scene...more
IMPEL welcomes Musou Music Publishing — the first Greek publisher to join its collective
Musou Music Publishing is part of Musou Music Group, which was founded in 2006 and also includes Musou Music Production, Musou Studios, and Musou Records. Musou Music Publishing has been awarded a total of three Grand, eight Golden, three Silver and...more
BPI's new Yearbook reveals Country music's surging popularity, achieving its biggest annual share of the UK recorded music market this century
BPI’s newly-published All About The Music 2025 discloses Country’s share of the UK singles market increased by over 50% year-on-year in 2024, thanks to artists including Beyoncé, Dasha and Shaboozey. Country music claimed it highest share of artist albums consumption in the UK...more
ABBA co-founder and CISAC President Bjorn Ulvaeus urges UK government not to weaken copyright for AI
CISAC President Björn Ulvaeus has concluded two days of meetings in the UK, urging the government to safeguard human creators in the AI age and avoid weakening creators’ rights. Speaking at an open discussion with Members of Parliament and Lords in...more
THE HEADLINES
Spotify’s latest update gives users more control over their listening experience (see Digital)
Has music reached peak fragmentation? (see Analysis)
How LA is rebuilding the music industry after the fires (see Features)
Ministers reconsider changes to UK copyright law ahead of vote (see News)
How Ticketmaster swallowed the live entertainment scene (see Features)
Spotify executive on why 'per-stream rate' is one of the most misleading metrics in music (see Opinion)
BPI responds to government’s proposed amendments to the Data Bill related to AI and copyright (see News)
‘AI and intellectual property — a pivotal moment for the UK’s creative industries’ (see Opinion)
BPI's new Yearbook reveals Country music's surging popularity (see News)
How Live Nation calls the tune for the live music industry (see Features)
How economic volatility will impact US labels’ fandom monetisation push (see Comment)
Spotify is said to be raising its subscription prices across Europe and Latin America (see Digital)
Culture Secretary to review the Music Export Growth Scheme (see News)
The music industry wants solutions. But do listeners see problems? (see Comment)
The next generation of independent music tastemakers (see Features)